
The African National Congress Youth League (ANCYL) has mounted a spirited defence of its relevance and political standing, dismissing suggestions that the once-powerful youth movement has been reduced to a dormant extension of the ANC — devoid of the militancy, influence and organisational vibrancy associated with the eras of its former leaders Julius Malema and the late Peter Mokaba.
In an interview with African Times News, ANCYL First Deputy Secretary-General Tsakani Shiviti has rejected claims that the organisation has lost its political significance, insisting that the youth league remains a formidable political force, capable of shaping the country’s political discourse, producing future leaders and championing the interests of young people.
Shiviti’s remarks come amid growing criticism over the perceived diminishing influence of the youth league within the governing ANC, particularly following Limpopo Premier Phophi Ramathuba’s decision to leave provincial ANCYL chairperson Faith Sebopela out of her provincial executive council.
Independent political analyst Magic Nkhwashu interpreted Sebopela’s exclusion as a further indication that the youth league’s influence within the ANC has waned, arguing that the organisation no longer commands the political authority and visibility it enjoyed under the leadership of Mokaba and Malema.
Nkhwashu went as far as describing the current ANCYL as little more than an ANC desk, suggesting that it had lost the combative political character and organisational dynamism that once made it an influential force in the country’s political landscape.
At national level, the current ANCYL leadership has been accused of lacking the usual roar that saw the likes Malema and Mokaba wielding ernomous power, and influencing ANC policies and deployments to key government positions. Under Collen Malatji, the league has been seen as an extension of the mother body after its leaders usually awaited a cue from the ANC leadership before pronouncing on major issues.
Speaking to African Times News on the sidelines of the inauguration of newly elected Collins Chabane Local Municipality Mayor Hlulani Matshebele at Malamulele Community Hall last week, Shiviti took exception to the characterisation, arguing that the organisation’s institutional identity should never be conflated with the personalities who have occupied its leadership positions.
“The ANCYL cannot be compared to an individual. It’s very wrong to compare the ANCYL to an individual. The ANCYL is an organisation.
“That individual joined the organisation, and he left the organisation. And the organisation is still here. It has produced more leaders and more vibrant leaders,” Shiviti said.
Although she did not explicitly mention Malema by name, her remarks appeared to address criticism that the youth league has struggled to reproduce the political energy and influence associated with his tenure.
Malema, who previously led the ANCYL, was expelled from the ANC on February 29, 2012 before establishing the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) on 26 July 2013.
Nkhwashu had argued that the organisation’s current leadership, under Malatji, paled in comparison to the political stature of Mokaba and Malema, both of whom emerged from Limpopo and left an indelible mark on the country’s political landscape.
“The ANCYL is just a desk. It is not the same as when Peter Mokaba and Julius Malema were the leaders. It is not as vibrant. Phophi decided to go with her faction and ignored the ANCYL. It is just a desk being used by anyone there,” Nkhwashu had said.
However, Shiviti maintained that such comparisons were misplaced, arguing that the ANCYL’s historical significance, political contribution and leadership legacy predated both former presidents.
She invoked the organisation’s illustrious history, citing some of the country’s most prominent political figures who emerged from its ranks, including its founding president Anton Lembede, former president Nelson Mandela and struggle stalwart Oliver Tambo.
“The ANCYL is vibrant. You can’t take away the vibrancy from the ANCYL, because from generation to generation, the ANCYL has produced leaders. [It] produced Anton Lembede, produced Nelson Mandela, [and] produced Oliver Tambo,” she insisted.
Shiviti further suggested that if political comparisons were to be made, the current generation of leaders should be measured against the calibre of those who preceded them, rather than judging the entire organisation through the performance or personality of one former leader.
“If we are to compare that leader [Malema], we would rather compare him to the leaders that led before him. That is, not as vibrant as the leaders who led the ANCYL before him,” she maintained.
Defending the Malatji-led ANCYL, Shiviti insisted that it remained firmly rooted in the political and socio-economic struggles confronting young South Africans, dismissing suggestions that it had become detached from the realities facing its constituency.
She maintained that the organisation continued to play an active role in representing young people and influencing the broader political direction of the country.
“We are leading the Youth League now, and the Youth League is vibrant. The Youth League is responsive to the challenges of young people.
“And the ANCYL is the only biggest youth movement in the entire country. And the whole continent,” she said.


