Opens in a new tab

Western Hypocrisy: From Norway to the Congo to Johannesburg

  • Nobel Prizes, Gaza, the Congo, French Repression, and South African Municipal Elections
South Africa Celebrates as Navi Pillay Wins 2026 Nobel Peace Prize
Veteran human rights lawyer and jurist Justice Navanethem “Navi” Pillay has been awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize for her lifelong contribution to international law, justice and the protection of human rights. Photo: Nobel Prize

SOUTH AFRICANS and many peace-loving people around the world lauded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize winner, attorney and human rights protagonist, Navi Pillay, for her tireless work over many decades in the field of human rights and justice, particularly in her role as United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights from 2008 through 2014 and as a judge of the International Criminal Court and president of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

Pillay has consistently defended the rights of the oppressed, particularly during the ongoing genocide in Gaza.

That Pillay’s accolades, announced on October 9, 2026, have not been as universally acclaimed is an indication that war and genocide are more welcomed than the peace and common humanity the world needs most right now.

The core question is the manner in which the regimes of Western Europe and its diaspora arrogantly assert themselves as primary custodians of human rights and democracy in the world.

Leading examples include the United Nations, UNESCO, the UN human rights system, the World Trade Organisation, the International Criminal Court, the International Court of Justice, the World Health Organisation, the World Food Programme, the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the Food and Agriculture Organisation, the European Union Court of Justice, and various other such international fora.

The message constantly churned out is that these organisations enable the world to reflect stability and a “level playing field for all.”

Yet, all of these reputedly global-stabilising organisations were initiated, without exception, from regimes and regions where the most invasive inhumane practices were headquartered and formally launched as state policy in Western Europe.

The dramatic irony is that nations which were responsible for the chattel enslavement of Africans and outright colonial occupation of all regions of the world are also the same nations that initiated these ostensible human rights-protecting organisations.

These colonial nations still exercise disproportionately unjust economic, political, and military control of the world, now challenged by rising nations like China, Russia, and Iran. The hypocrisy of Western rhetoric on human rights is reflected in the recent repression of hundreds of thousands of young people in Western Europe, particularly in France and Italy. This is where protests against underfunded education, economic hardship, and bloated military spending have unleashed some of the most violent armed police responses, even to mostly peaceful protests, on the basis of “law and order” at all costs.

The draconian measures included shooting or harming the bodies of young students.

When these ostensibly philanthropic prizes and accolades are awarded to persons or organisations in the Global South, thinking people need to consistently raise questions: What’s the source? Why now? For instance, the Nobel Prize was founded in honour of Alfred Nobel, the Norwegian who experimented with explosives at a small lab on his father’s estate.

In 1867, even after an explosion killed his younger brother and many others, Nobel proceeded to experiment with nitroglycerine absorbed in porous siliceous earth material, producing dynamite. Thus, the mining and arms explosion industries were launched, a legacy that has annihilated millions of people bombed by explosives globally, first by Italy over Libya in 1911, through two intra-European wars from 1914-1918 and 1939-1945 respectively, to the Congo, Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Korea, Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia in the previous century, to Iraq, Afghanistan, Somalia, Syria, Libya, Iran, and Lebanon and Occupied Palestine, Gaza in particular, presently.

Mining by dynamite that has pulverised mountains, rivers, hills, valleys, and plains, for gold and other mineral wealth, is Nobel’s other ugly legacy that has destroyed sacred places of Indigenous peoples globally over 160 years.

What better way to reinvent a bomber inventor and arms-expansion businessman who made millions of kroner over decades from his invention than to formulate an international prize of hundreds of thousands of kroner for those involved in medicine, physics, chemistry, economic science, literature, and unbelievably, peace?

This is illustrative of the myriad duplicitous initiatives that emanate from the colonial regimes of the west that consistently portray their actions as just and honest, but contradictorily and hypocritically practice the total opposite.

The ongoing genocide in Gaza, where an entire dispossessed refugee people who have been subjected to over 200,000 tons of bombs¹ still face daily bombing and shooting by the Israeli Occupation Force (IOF) even while living in rubble, and now in rain-soaked tents, is a striking case.

These heinous deeds are perpetrated by the Israeli apartheid colonial regime that was found by the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry, chaired by Pillay, to have committed genocide in Gaza, with two of its responsible leaders, Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant, still wanted by the International Criminal Court. Yet the US and Western countries still protect and fund perpetrators of cruelty while claiming to be the global leaders of human rights and
justice.

Instead, they have participated in military bombing campaigns against Iran that have killed thousands of people, including 156 people at the Shajareh Tayyebeh Elementary School in Minab on February 28, 2026, among them 120 children²
.
The “white man speaks with forked tongue” is a long-time colloquial expression among Indigenous people of occupied Turtle Island (North America). Of the 370 treaties between the US European settler-colonialist government and hundreds of Indigenous Indian nations, zero were honoured.

Patrice Lumumba was murdered for his call for Congolese independence from the west by the CIA, the Belgians, and their acolyte forces in 1961, even though he was democratically elected.

At the Lancaster House agreement in 1979, when Zimbabwean independence was agreed to, the British government promised to provide compensation to white farmers whose land would be expropriated for redistribution among the millions of landless Black people.

The British reneged on this agreement and, along with the US and other Western regimes, imposed comprehensive economic sanctions after the Mugabe government expropriated land from 4,000 white farmers who owned 47% of the most productive land.

The June 16 Memorandum of Understanding between the US regime and Iran was violently abrogated by the constant US military attacks on Iran, particularly in the south around Keshm Island and Bandar Abbas, and a naval blockade.

Coming to recent municipal elections in South Africa, the white-led Democratic Alliance (DA) that has refused to support restorative economic and land justice for the millions of Black people dispossessed over 374 years, is now making headway into impoverished and marginalised Black communities, wooing voters with chimerical promises of jobs, effective public services, and economic prosperity.

The DA has capitalised on the deep frustration of millions of people with the inept ruling ANC government for its consistent failure over 32 years to provide basic services like water, electricity, and sanitation to Black townships nationally.

The DA has received 24.64% of the national vote and secured 1,695 seats, lower than the ANC’s dismal 30.76% nationally, but received the largest proportion of votes in metropolitan centres, Johannesburg, Tshwane, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay, and Cape Town.

Again, the veins of western hypocrisy are evident in the cheap and devious political ploys deployed by parties like the DA. The saddest and most disturbing element is the manner that colonised Black people can still cherish faith in a morally decrepit organisation like the DA that has failed to extricate millions from abject impoverishment in the Cape Flats and townships like Crossroads, Khayelitsha, Kraaifontein, and Dunoon in the DA-administered Western Cape.

Internalised oppression among Black people is still entrenched. Black people and all oppressed and dispossessed marginalised people everywhere must come to understand the fundamental fraud and veiled hypocrisy of Western institutions and organisations that employ the most persuasive rhetoric in their relationships with the oppressed, yet consistently do the direct opposite and undermine true liberation, justice, peace, and dignity.

Depending on the empty promises of these fraudulent organisations for justice and sustenance is like inviting a fox to lead the chickens to the chicken house.

In this sense, Steve Biko’s life and Black Consciousness philosophy and practice that was commemorated on September 12 and on October 19, sheds a glaring light on the unassailable truth: “Black Man/Woman, you’re on your own!”

Dependency on white philanthropy and Western humanistic rhetoric and discourse is but an exercise in futility.

Professor Julian Kunnie

Julian Kunnie is Professor Extraordinarius at UNISA and an activist researcher, author, and advocate for the Earth Mother and Indigenous peoples. His major book publications include: The Earth Mother and the Assault of Capitalism: Living Sustainably with All Life (McFarland & Company, 2025); The Cost of Globalization: Dangers to the Earth and Its People (McFarland & Company, 2015); Pan Africanist Working Class Cultural Critical Perspectives (Westview Press/Perseus Books, 2000). He works with the Black Consciousness Movement, Black Alliance for Peace, the Indigenous Peoples’ Movement for Self Determination and Liberation, and is a supporter of Abahlali BaseMjondolo and the Palestine solidarity movement.

Author

RELATED TOPICS

Related Articles

African Times News